-
A frustrated parent grappling with a family boundary dispute is represented by a man sitting indoors with his face in his hand.
-
WIBTAH for giving my mother an ultimatum for disrespecting my wife?
-
I (25 yo male) have been married to my wife (25 yo female) for 1 year at the time of the incident.
-
My sister was having a wedding. My wife and I were invited to stay at a air bnb with my mom, dad, step-dad, brother, uncle and cousin. The day we came to the airport bnb we left around 9-10 pm so that our child (<1 yo) would sleep the whole ride (3 hours). We were wrong. Despite other times where this would occur, this was the exception. We went nearly the whole trip with a crying baby until the last 10 minutes of the drive. When we arrived, my wife took our son inside who wakes up from the exchange and starts crying again. I, at this time, am getting our luggage and bags out of the car for the visit. My mom greets my wife and asks to take our son. Our son gets further upset. My wife asks my mom to hand him back. My mom refuses and walks away. My wife follows her and they get into an argument. My mom tells my wife that the only way for our son to get to know my mom is that she gets time to bond with him. My wife tells her that this isn't the time and she is a stranger to my son. At this time, I am walking in, seeing my mom give our son to my wife and we head to our room. We talk about what happened and she thinks she made my mom upset. We agree its been a long night, she was drinking and its fine. No grudges held.
-
Next day (day of the wedding), I needed a haircut and my wife was fine with being left at the place with my family. While out, my wife says that my mom isn't talking or even acknowledging her presence while everyone else is. I return to the place and talk casually with my mom. My wife is able to talk during the conversation and my mom responds to her. I also give her a late mother's day gift because I wasn't able to sooner. She appreciates it and we have a good time laughing talking about it the three of us. My wife refuses to bring up last night or this morning at this time because she doesn't want to ruin my sister's wedding in any regard. Nothing else happens this day.
-
Next day, my brother approaches me telling me to make sure my wife watches what she says to my mother. I (confused because of his tone and obvious threat) ask him to tell me what he's talking about. My brother talks about how my wife was imploite the first night when me and my wife arrive. We end up having a little back and forth where I (lightly) defend my wife, since I am still scared of my brother and he's always kept it that way. My wife ends up walking in on our talk and my brother tells her, at first, not to worry about it and thats its a family matter. I defend my wife more by saying she's allowed in this conversation because she is apart of the family. My brother is hesitant and still trying to force me to kick her out of it, but I don't budge. My brother and wife end up talking about the situation and he ends up saying that both sides are valid. We agree that my wife, mom, brother and myself should all sit down before me and my wife leave that night. (It was also revealed during this discussion that my mom talked to everyone about what happened after we went to our room that first night).
-
Later, I talk to my mom telling her that she, my wife, brother and myself need to talk and she says no. She says that my wife and her need to talk and that she didn't appreciate my wife's tone. I emphasize exactly what I said and leave her alone.
-
Cut to the present. My wife and I have talked extensively on the subject. She is ready to forgive my mom while I am not. We were ready to forgive her walking off with our son which was disobeying my wife who, we and everyone we talked to about it, agrees my wife and I have complete authority over not the grandparents. However, after learning that my mom was two-faced with my wife by not even acknowledging her and talking behind our backs, I've come to the conclusion that I won't tolerate disrespect for my wife and I won't tolerate my mom thinking she has full authority over a child she has seen only 3 times in almost a year.
-
My son's birthday is coming up in a few weeks and we want to hold a party. I am hesitant to give my mom an ultimatum. Either she comes with an apology or she doesn't come at all. This will extend throughout his life. If my mom doesn't apologize to my wife, she won't be able to see her first and currently only grandchild until she is adult enough to do so.
-
I'm hoping my mom's desire to see her only grandchild will overcome her pride, but I'm honestly okay with either scenario.
-
A strained family boundary decision is reflected by a man sitting alone with his face covered in frustration
-
The thing that makes it worse is how fast the whole vibe turns from awkward to petty. One night becomes a silent treatment situation. Then comes the family whisper campaign, which is always a classy move. Nothing says maturity like turning a personal annoyance into a group project and letting everyone pick a side. Suddenly the wife is expected to smile through it, the husband is trying to keep the peace, and the brother shows up with the energy of a guy who thinks intimidation is a communication style.
What is really going on here is less about one argument and more about who gets to act like they have authority in a new family. Grandparents love to forget that being related to a baby does not magically make them the boss of the baby. Parents are still the parents. That part is not complicated. But some people hear that and act like it is a temporary suggestion they can argue with if they are confident enough.
The ultimatum question makes sense because once the disrespect starts spreading into side conversations and family gossip, it stops being a misunderstanding and starts being a pattern. At that point, an apology is not about politeness. It is about whether someone is willing to recognize boundaries instead of rewriting them to make themselves feel important. And yes, a grandchild’s birthday is a lovely time to test whether a grown adult can admit they were out of line before showing up for cake.
It's not harsh to want respect before access. It's just basic house rules, except the house now includes a baby, which apparently makes everybody forget theirs.
Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.